On this page

Are tracking pixels illegal on health websites? Not in themselves, but HHS says HIPAA regulated entities “are not permitted to use tracking technologies in a manner that would result in impermissible disclosures of PHI to tracking technology vendors,” and a June 20, 2024 court order vacated only one part of that guidance: the part saying an IP address plus a visit to a public page about a health condition or provider triggers HIPAA. Curve Compliance's free website scan lists the pixels and trackers a page loads, and Curve replaces browser ad pixels with server-side tracking that strips PHI before data reaches an ad platform.

Book a call. Want to know what your pixels actually send? Curve's team reviews what your website sends to Meta, Google and TikTok with you and shows what's likely triggering a flag. Book a call with Curve.

What does HHS say about tracking pixels?

HHS defines the thing first: “A web beacon or tracking pixel is a tiny graphic image (usually 1 pixel) placed on a webpage that allows the website owner or a third party to collect information regarding the use of the webpage that contains the web beacon” (HHS).

HHS says the HIPAA Rules apply “when the information that regulated entities collect through tracking technologies or disclose to tracking technology vendors includes protected health information (PHI).” Where they apply, HHS says “Regulated entities must ensure that all tracking technology vendors have signed a BAA and that there is an applicable permission prior to a disclosure of PHI.” A consent pop-up doesn't substitute: “Website banners that ask users to accept or reject a website’s use of tracking technologies, such as cookies, do not constitute a valid HIPAA authorization.”

“Tracking technologies on a regulated entity’s user-authenticated webpages generally have access to PHI,” and a public page that lets people book appointments or use a symptom checker “may have access to PHI in certain circumstances” (HHS). If PHI goes to a vendor without a permission and a BAA, HHS says “there is a presumption that there has been a breach of unsecured PHI unless the regulated entity can demonstrate that there is a low probability that the PHI has been compromised.” HHS notes that the bulletin itself does “not have the force and effect of law”; it explains how HHS reads the HIPAA Rules, which do.

What did the 2024 court ruling change?

HHS puts the ruling at the top of its own page: “On June 20, 2024, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas issued an order declaring unlawful and vacating a portion of this guidance document” (HHS). The case is American Hospital Association v. Becerra. HHS says the court vacated the guidance to the extent it said HIPAA obligations are triggered in “circumstances where an online technology connects (1) an individual’s IP address with (2) a visit to a[n] [unauthenticated public webpage] addressing specific health conditions or healthcare providers.” HHS adds: “HHS is evaluating its next steps in light of that order.”

In plain terms, the vacated part is the claim that an IP address plus a visit to a public page about a condition or a provider is enough, by itself, to bring HIPAA in. The rest of the bulletin is still on HHS's page, covering logged-in pages, scheduling and symptom-checker pages, mobile apps and the BAA requirement. For the bulletin annotated line by line, see the HHS tracking bulletin after AHA v. Becerra.

Here is where the main rules stand, checked November 20, 2026:

Law or guidanceWho it reachesWhat it says
HIPAA, with the HHS tracking bulletinHIPAA covered entities and business associatesNo impermissible disclosures of PHI to tracking vendors; a BAA and a permission before any disclosure
AHA v. Becerra order (June 20, 2024)The HHS bulletinVacated the part about an IP address plus a visit to a public page about a condition or provider
FTC Health Breach Notification RuleVendors of personal health records, PHR related entities and their service providersSharing covered information without authorization can trigger breach notice
FTC Act, Section 5Companies generallyProhibits misleading consumers and unfair practices; cited in the FTC's GoodRx complaint
Washington My Health My Data ActRegulated entities and small businesses handling consumer health dataSeparate consent to collect and to share; a consumer health data privacy policy
California Penal Code 631Any personReading a communication in transit without the consent of all parties

Does the FTC's Health Breach Notification Rule apply to you?

Only if you are outside HIPAA and in its scope. The FTC says the Rule applies if you are “a vendor of personal health records (PHRs); a PHR related entity; or a third party service provider for a vendor of PHRs or a PHR related entity,” and that “You’re not a vendor of personal health records if you’re covered by HIPAA” (FTC). It also says “July 2024 amendments make clear that makers of health apps, connected devices, and similar products must comply with the Rule.”

The FTC ties the Rule directly to advertising. It says “Incidents of unauthorized access, including a company’s disclosure of covered information without a person’s authorization, triggers notification obligations under the Rule,” and gives this example of covered information: “suppose you share your users’ medical information along with their mobile identifiers with an ad network for the purpose of targeted marketing without first getting the person’s consent” (FTC).

The FTC has used the Rule and the FTC Act against health advertisers. On February 1, 2023, it announced it had “taken enforcement action for the first time under its Health Breach Notification Rule against the telehealth and prescription drug discount provider GoodRx Holdings Inc.” According to the FTC's complaint, GoodRx shared users' prescription medications and health conditions with advertising platforms such as Facebook, Google and Criteo. Under the proposed order, “GoodRx will be permanently prohibited from disclosing user health information with applicable third parties for advertising purposes” (FTC, February 1, 2023). On March 2, 2023, the FTC announced a proposed order against BetterHelp; according to the complaint, the company revealed email addresses, IP addresses and health questionnaire information to Facebook, Snapchat and others for advertising (FTC, March 2, 2023). More in FTC health privacy cases and who the FTC rule covers beyond HIPAA.

What do state laws such as Washington's add?

Washington's My Health My Data Act (RCW 19.373.900) reaches health data that HIPAA doesn't. It defines consumer health data as “personal information that is linked or reasonably linkable to a consumer and that identifies the consumer's past, present, or future physical or mental health status,” and the list includes “Data that identifies a consumer seeking health care services” (RCW 19.373.010). It doesn't apply to information that meets the definition of protected health information under HIPAA (RCW 19.373.100), so for a HIPAA covered clinic the question becomes which website data is PHI and which is consumer health data.

Where it applies, a regulated entity “may not collect any consumer health data except” with consent for a specified purpose or as needed to provide what the consumer asked for. The same two exceptions apply to sharing, but the consent to share must be one “that is separate and distinct from the consent obtained to collect consumer health data” (RCW 19.373.030). It also requires a regulated entity and a small business to “maintain a consumer health data privacy policy” and to “prominently publish a link to its consumer health data privacy policy on its homepage” (RCW 19.373.020). A violation “is an unfair or deceptive act in trade or commerce and an unfair method of competition for the purpose of applying the consumer protection act, chapter 19.86 RCW” (RCW 19.373.090). See Washington's My Health My Data Act for healthcare marketing.

Some states have older privacy laws worth knowing. California's Penal Code 631 covers anyone who, “willfully and without the consent of all parties to the communication,” reads or tries “to learn the contents or meaning of any message, report, or communication while the same is in transit” (California Penal Code 631). Whether that reaches website tracking is covered in California SB 690 and CIPA for healthcare websites and in Curve's healthcare pixel lawsuit tracker.

How do you check what pixels your site loads?

Start with a list. Tag managers, booking widgets and chat tools all bring their own scripts.

  • Run the free website scan on your homepage, a service page, the booking page and a thank-you page. It lists the pixels and trackers each page loads.
  • Open your tag manager and list every tag, its trigger and the pages it fires on.
  • In your browser's developer tools, watch the Network tab as each page loads and check what each request to an ad or analytics service carries.
  • Walk the full path a patient takes, from the ad to the confirmation page, including any scheduler or intake tool on another domain.

Whether a given pixel on your site is lawful depends on what kind of entity you are, which pages it runs on, what it sends and where your patients live, so talk to your counsel with that list in hand. For the wider question of web tracking on health sites, see website tracking on health sites, and for the Meta pixel specifically, is the Meta pixel HIPAA compliant?

How Curve Compliance helps

Curve Compliance starts with what your site loads today: the free website scan lists the pixels and trackers on a page, and Curve's team reviews what your website sends to Meta, Google and TikTok with you and shows what's likely triggering a flag. Curve then replaces browser ad pixels with one script and sends conversions server-side from Curve's servers to the Meta Conversions API, Google Ads, TikTok, Microsoft Advertising and LinkedIn, with PHI stripped before data reaches an ad platform.

Each platform receives only a fixed list of fields. Curve detects PHI-like patterns, such as condition names, form answers and emails in URLs, and flags them so they can be stopped at the source, and Event Logs show what Curve sent to each platform and what the platform accepted. Curve signs a BAA on every plan, is SOC 2 Type II, and its team does the setup, typically live in about a week. Book a call to go through your scan results with Curve's team.

Sources, checked November 20, 2026: HHS OCR: Use of Online Tracking Technologies; FTC: Complying with FTC's Health Breach Notification Rule; FTC: GoodRx proposed order (February 1, 2023); FTC: BetterHelp proposed order (March 2, 2023); RCW 19.373.900 (short title); RCW 19.373.010 (definitions); RCW 19.373.020 (privacy policy); RCW 19.373.030 (collection and sharing); RCW 19.373.090 (consumer protection act); RCW 19.373.100 (exemptions); California Penal Code 631.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are tracking pixels illegal?

Not in themselves, but HHS says HIPAA regulated entities may not use them in a way that results in impermissible disclosures of PHI, and the FTC and states such as Washington add their own rules for health data outside HIPAA.

Is the Meta pixel a HIPAA violation?

Not automatically. It becomes a problem when a HIPAA regulated entity's pixel sends PHI to Meta without a permission, since HHS says regulated entities “must ensure that all tracking technology vendors have signed a BAA” before disclosing PHI (HHS); see is the Meta pixel HIPAA compliant?

Does HIPAA still apply to tracking after AHA v. Becerra?

Yes. The June 20, 2024 order vacated the part of HHS's guidance about an IP address plus a visit to a public page about health conditions or providers; the HIPAA Rules still apply whenever tracking discloses PHI (HHS).

Who does the FTC Health Breach Notification Rule cover?

Vendors of personal health records, PHR related entities and their third party service providers, which the FTC says includes makers of health apps and connected devices; a business covered by HIPAA is not a vendor of personal health records (FTC).

Does Washington's My Health My Data Act require a privacy policy?

Yes. A regulated entity and a small business “shall maintain a consumer health data privacy policy” and must link to it prominently on the homepage (RCW 19.373.020).

How do I find the pixels on my website?

Run Curve Compliance's free website scan, which lists the pixels and trackers a page loads, then check your tag manager and the booking and thank-you pages by hand.

Not for HIPAA. HHS says “Website banners that ask users to accept or reject a website’s use of tracking technologies, such as cookies, do not constitute a valid HIPAA authorization” (HHS).

Talk to Curve Compliance

Book a call. Want your pixels replaced with server-side tracking that strips PHI before data reaches an ad platform? Curve's team does the setup, typically live in about a week, under the BAA Curve signs on every plan. Book a call with Curve.