Learning from BetterHelp's $7M Fine: Prevention Strategies for Cardiology Practices
In today's digital landscape, cardiology practices face unique HIPAA compliance challenges when advertising online. BetterHelp's recent $7 million fine serves as a stark reminder of what's at stake when tracking technologies mishandle protected health information (PHI). Cardiology practices, which routinely deal with sensitive cardiac conditions, patient medications, and treatment plans, must navigate digital marketing with extra caution to avoid similar penalties while still effectively reaching patients in need of care.
The High-Stakes Compliance Risks for Cardiology Practices
Cardiology practices face specific vulnerabilities when implementing tracking pixels and advertising tools that weren't initially designed with healthcare compliance in mind. Here are three critical risks:
1. Condition-Specific Data Leakage in Heart Health Campaigns
When cardiology practices run campaigns targeting specific cardiac conditions like "afib treatment" or "heart failure management," they can inadvertently expose patient information through URL parameters, form submissions, or conversion events. Meta's broad targeting systems may associate user identities with these condition-specific searches or website visits, creating what the OCR has determined constitutes PHI transmission without proper authorization.
2. Remarketing Pixels Capturing Diagnostic Information
Standard client-side tracking pixels from Google and Meta can capture URL paths, form fields, and other on-page elements that might contain diagnostic codes, medication information, or procedure details. For cardiology practices using ICD-10 codes in their URL structure or patient portals, this presents significant exposure risk.
3. Third-Party Cookie Vulnerabilities in Patient Journey Tracking
The HHS Office for Civil Rights has explicitly addressed tracking technologies in their December 2022 guidance, stating that when tracking technologies transmit PHI to third parties without authorization, they violate HIPAA rules. This is particularly problematic for cardiology practices tracking patient conversion journeys across multiple touchpoints.
Client-side tracking (the traditional method) places code directly on your website where it can access form inputs, URL parameters, and other potentially sensitive data. Server-side tracking, by contrast, filters data through a secure intermediary server before sending anonymized conversion data to ad platforms—creating a critical compliance buffer for cardiology practices.
HIPAA-Compliant Solutions for Cardiology Marketing
Addressing these compliance challenges requires a systematic approach to digital marketing that prioritizes patient privacy while maintaining marketing effectiveness.
How Curve's PHI Stripping Works for Cardiology Practices
Curve implements a dual-layer approach to PHI protection:
Client-Side Protection: Curve's tracking code includes pre-filtering algorithms specifically designed to identify and strip cardiac condition terms, diagnostic codes, and medication references before they ever leave the browser.
Server-Side Sanitization: All tracking data passes through Curve's HIPAA-compliant server environment where advanced pattern matching identifies and removes any remaining PHI before secure transmission to advertising platforms via their official APIs.
Implementation for Cardiology-Specific Systems
For cardiology practices, integration follows these steps:
Curve provides a customized tracking snippet optimized for cardiology websites and patient portals
The system connects with cardiology-specific EHR systems like Epic Cardiology or Cardio Server through secure API endpoints
Custom PHI detection rules are configured for cardiac-specific terminologies
Server-side connections are established with Google Ads API and Meta CAPI
Signed BAAs ensure HIPAA compliance throughout the data flow
This implementation creates a secure pathway for conversion tracking while maintaining the effectiveness of your cardiology practice's digital campaigns.
Optimization Strategies for HIPAA Compliant Cardiology Marketing
Beyond implementing compliant tracking infrastructure, cardiology practices can adopt these strategies to maximize marketing effectiveness while maintaining compliance:
1. Create Condition-Agnostic Conversion Pathways
Develop generalized form submissions and landing pages that don't reveal specific cardiac conditions in URLs or page content. For example, use "Schedule a Consultation" rather than "Atrial Fibrillation Evaluation Request." This prevents condition-specific information from being captured by tracking tools while still enabling effective conversion measurement.
2. Leverage Aggregated Audience Targeting
Rather than targeting highly specific cardiac conditions, use Google and Meta's broader health interest categories combined with demographic data relevant to cardiovascular risk factors. This approach maintains targeting effectiveness while reducing compliance risks associated with condition-specific campaigns.
3. Implement Enhanced Conversions Through Compliant Channels
Google's Enhanced Conversions and Meta's Conversion API offer powerful optimization tools when implemented compliantly. Curve's server-side integration enables cardiology practices to take advantage of these features by transmitting conversion data without PHI, improving campaign performance while maintaining strict compliance standards.
By transmitting only hashed, non-PHI data elements like anonymized conversion events, cardiology practices can benefit from platform optimization algorithms without exposing protected information.
Taking Action to Protect Your Cardiology Practice
BetterHelp's $7 million settlement demonstrates that regulatory bodies are actively enforcing HIPAA compliance in digital marketing. Cardiology practices handling sensitive patient information face even greater scrutiny and potential penalties.
With Curve's HIPAA-compliant tracking solution, your practice can confidently run effective Google and Meta ads while maintaining rigorous privacy standards. Our system's specialized PHI stripping technology and server-side implementation eliminate the risks that led to BetterHelp's costly settlement.
Ready to run compliant Google/Meta ads?
Book a HIPAA Strategy Session with Curve
Jan 17, 2025